Not almond, not oat: the plant milk baristas quietly prefer for proper foam in flat whites

The jug looked promising. The barista had done everything right: purged the wand, angled the pitcher, listened for that soft paper‑tearing hiss. But as he poured, the almond milk slid out thin and flat, a beige tide with a few stubborn bubbles. No gloss, no definition. The rosetta he drew on autopilot dissolved before the cup hit the saucer.

Later, the same barista reached for a different carton. Not oat; the shop’s busiest milk by a mile. A plain, unshowy soy. This time the foam was denser, silkier, almost elastic. The flat white landed on the counter with a proper sheen and a heart that held its shape right down to the last sip.

In plant‑milk culture wars, almond and oat dominate the conversation. In the pitcher, they don’t always dominate the performance. Behind the machine, a quieter favourite holds its ground.

Why soy still wins behind the bar

Talk to baristas off the record and a pattern appears. Customers ask for oat, menus list almond, coconut and hazelnut - but when staff pour a “how we’d drink it” flat white for themselves, soy is the default.

“If I’ve got one shot to pour clean latte art with a plant milk, I’m reaching for soy every time,” one London head barista told me. “It just behaves.”

The reason is not nostalgia; it is chemistry. Proper microfoam relies on protein to stretch and trap air in ultra‑fine bubbles. Dairy has plenty of it. Soy runs closest in both quantity and structure, which means:

• Foam builds fast and holds its shape.
• The texture skews glossy rather than bubbly.
• Designs stay crisp instead of bleeding into the crema.

Almond, by comparison, is lean on protein and high on water. Oat has more body but can tip into porridge‑adjacent, especially when overheated. Soy sits in that narrow band: enough structure to stretch, enough fat to feel creamy, not so much starch that it turns gummy.

The flat white test: what really matters in the cup

Flat whites are unforgiving. There is nowhere for bad foam to hide. You are aiming for a very specific set of conditions: a short drink, fine microfoam, and a seamless blend with espresso.

Baristas look for three things:

1. Stretch – how easily the milk takes air at the start.
2. Shine – the wet‑paint gloss that signals tight microfoam.
3. Stability – whether the texture and art hold as the drink cools.

Soy tends to tick all three. It stretches quickly without screaming, polishes to a shine with minimal tapping and swirling, and stays integrated rather than splitting into layers. Oat can hit two out of three on a good day; almond rarely manages one.

A quick comparison in the pitcher

Milk type	What drinkers love	What baristas fight
Almond	Light, nutty, low‑calorie image	Weak foam, big bubbles, sudden splitting
Oat	Sweet, creamy, “dairy‑adjacent”	Risk of slimy texture, scorchy flavour when hot
Soy	Balanced taste, proven foaming	Occasional curdling in very bright, acidic espresso

Pea‑based “barista blends” now enter the chat, borrowing soy’s protein logic with a more neutral flavour. In many speciality cafés they’re a quiet second choice - an option for guests who avoid soy but still want latte art that looks like the photos.

Why your oat latte looks fine but your flat white doesn’t

If you’ve ever wondered why cafés push you towards oat for lattes yet pull a face when you suggest it for a flat white, this is why. Taller milk drinks forgive a lot. Foam can be slightly coarse, sweetness can run high, and the drink will still feel comforting.

Flat whites amplify flaws. Less volume means:

• Any instability shows up as visible separation.
• Over‑stretched foam tastes dry and meringue‑like.
• Excess starch from oat or rice milks gets claggy, fast.

Soy’s tighter microfoam knits with espresso instead of sitting on top. The result is closer to a dairy flat white: a single, silky phase where coffee and milk share the spotlight rather than wrestle for it.

The quiet rise of “barista” soy and pea blends

Supermarket aisles now heave with plant milks, but baristas treat them like ingredients, not interchangeable boxes. The formulas that win tend to share a few traits:

• Higher protein (often from soy or peas).
• Moderate fat, sometimes from added rapeseed or sunflower oil.
• Controlled sweetness, enough to round espresso without tasting like cereal milk.
• Heat stability, usually via precise pH tweaks and buffering salts.

Look for the word “barista” or “for professionals” on cartons if you plan to steam at home. It usually signals a formula tuned for foam, not porridge.

In the UK, several brands now offer both standard soy and “barista soy”. The latter whips faster, goes glossier and curdles less in very light, fruity coffees. Pea‑based options copy the template almost note for note, with a softer flavour that offends fewer palates.

How to coax proper foam from plant milks at home

You don’t need a commercial machine to see the difference, but you do need to adjust your habits. Plant milks are less forgiving than dairy once you add heat and air.

Try this with soy or a soy‑pea barista blend:

• Start colder: use milk straight from the fridge; plant proteins collapse quickly if they start warm.
• Stretch briefly: introduce air only for the first couple of seconds, just until the jug feels slightly fuller and the surface sound softens.
• Stop at a lower temperature: aim for 55–60°C. Above that, most plant milks thicken, dull in flavour and start to split.
• Polish patiently: once you’ve stopped adding air, bury the wand tip and create a gentle whirlpool until the surface looks reflective, not foamy.

If you are using a small home steam wand, work with smaller volumes (120–150 ml) so you can control the texture more precisely. For handheld frothers, stick religiously to soy or pea blends; they cope best with the relatively aggressive agitation.

Rethinking “healthy” when texture is the brief

Almond enjoys a health halo. Oat has a sustainability narrative. Soy, unfairly, has picked up years of half‑understood headlines. Inside cafés, the calculus is often more practical: which milk lets you serve drinks that look, feel and taste consistent?

From a home barista’s perspective, it may help to separate two questions:

• Which plant milk fits your diet, ethics and digestion?
• Within that choice, which specific product performs best in foam?

If you are flexible, soy - or a soy‑pea barista blend - remains the most reliable option for flat whites. If you’re committed to oat or nut milks, you can still chase better texture, but manage expectations. You are working against physics, not just technique.

What to ask (and watch) at your local café

The easiest way to learn is to pay quiet attention at the machine. Notice:

• Which carton gets opened for staff coffees.
• How different milks sound under steam - a harsh screech often signals struggling foam.
• Whether latte art appears on plant‑milk flat whites, or if the barista defaults to a simple blob.

You can also ask directly which milk they recommend for proper foam, not just for flavour. Baristas will usually light up; it is a rare chance to talk about something they think about all day and are seldom asked.

The plant milk baristas quietly prefer is the one that lets them do their job properly: stretch, swirl and pour a drink that behaves like coffee, not a compromise.

---

FAQ:

• Why does my soy milk sometimes curdle in coffee? High‑acid, very light‑roasted espresso can clash with soy’s proteins. Let the espresso cool for 20–30 seconds, swirl the soy well, and pour milk into coffee (not the other way round) to reduce shock.
• Is there a non‑soy option that still foams well? Pea‑based barista milks come closest in protein and behaviour. Look for “barista blend” on the label and avoid very low‑calorie versions, which tend to be too thin.
• Can I get good foam from oat milk for flat whites? You can get decent foam, especially with barista‑style oat, but it is more sensitive to overheating and can turn gloopy. Keep the temperature down and accept slightly less definition in latte art.
• Are all “barista” milks the same? No. Some are tuned more for sweetness than for foam. If possible, test a couple of brands; you’re looking for quick, fine foam and a satin finish, not big bubbles or marshmallow‑like froth.
• Does a better machine fix bad plant milk? A powerful steam wand helps, but it cannot invent protein or stability. Starting with the right milk matters more than upgrading from a basic home machine to a commercial one.